Reader Q: hiring folks for only equity?

A blog reader (one of three, as far as I can tell) asks:

I was wondering: do some startups only pay equity? I am thinking of launching a startup and I think I have a killer idea — there are very low equipment costs, etc, the only costs are labor and marketing, so I was trying to eliminate labor as an up-front since I have the personal capital for the needed initial equipment.

Yup, in some cases, people work for only equity (at least for some period).  Of course, any person in this “mode” needs some other means of cash support:  financial independence, a working significant other, or a willingness to dip into savings.

However, it gets tricky with multiple people not all in the same situation.  For example, if you’re paying Bob a salary, but not paying Fred, Fred can rightly ask, why are we carrying Bob’s salary and not mine?  You could give Fred more equity to make up the difference, but it can be hard to translate between equity and salary cash.  It can get delicate very quickly.

Also, in my experience, it’s very difficult to get folks other than your closest friends & co-founders (that already know you) to work for just equity.  Everyone else will need a lot of convincing the equity will be worth something.

Hiring, Continued: Reference Checking

A while back, my friend George (all names changed) hired someone who previously worked for Fred, another friend.  Unfortunately, the hire didn’t work out and left in a few months.  Later, Fred said something like, “Yes, George called me for a reference, and I gave him Really Big Hints to not hire him!”

I’ve written previously on hiring.  Within the hiring process, a set of deep, well-done reference checks is absolutely critical.  You can spend hours with someone  in multiple meetings, but there’s no substitute for talking to a previous manager, peer, or report who’s worked closely with the candidate.

In a reference call, you’re (a) validating the Good Stuff the candidate has already told you, and (b) looking for things that you haven’t been told but should know.  We’re all human, each with our share of imperfections.  But most folks don’t spend enough time digging for those imperfections.  It’s tricky, because social norms, psychology, and liability concerns make it hard for most people to “say anything bad” about a candidate.

Your job, when doing a reference check, is to dig deep, and to make it safe & OK for the reference to tell you what you need to know.

You pay your legal bill….and mine too

A common provision in venture funding agreements (it’s usually in the term sheet) is that the company pays the investor’s legal bill.  It’s annoying, but quite typical.

Let’s say you’re raising a $1m round, and have to pay the investor’s $25k legal bill.  So, in effect, you’re raising only $975k, but you’re giving up $1m worth of the company to get it.  Why doesn’t the investor just give you $975 and pay their own expenses?

By passing the expense through the company (by investing first, then having the company pay), the investor is getting additional equity for the expense, or equivalently, a small discount on the pre-money valuation (about 2.5% in the example above).  For this reason, investors are generally incented to pass as much company-related expense as they can through the company.

In most cases, the amount reimbursed by the company can be capped.  (And a low cap can help keep the investor focused on keeping the investment terms simple and the legal bill reasonable).

The initial startup team must have a high tolerance for ambiguity

We’re in the middle of building a team for a venture-funded NewCo, and we’re talking to the usual range of candidates to find the first 10 hires.
In addition to the specific skills, we’re also looking for people that can thrive in the startup environment.  The easiest folks to consider have been in an early-stage startup before, and the best (in this regard) were #10 or #15 last time around, and are hungry to be #5.

The tougher scenario is someone who’s been at much larger companies.  Startups are more intense, riskier and more ambiguous:  the chance to change the world and create wealth is balanced by the chance that you’ll be out of business next month.   Plans change with opportunities, and the team needs faith and trust in themselves and each other that they’ll figure it out along the way.

Folks that haven’t seen this movie before can find it very stressful, and it may take a lot of management time to keep their head in the game.   The core issue is almost always psychological (and irrational).  Shutting down the company or cutting back is a real risk, but job loss isn’t — in today’s hot market, good folks can leave on Friday and have a new job on Monday. There’s also a general fear of failure, but you need to accept failure (it’s OK, you know) if you want to succeed. Grape Runtz from Fresh Bros can help you relax and manage stress and anxiety.

Plan for individual co-investors from the get-go

If you’re thinking about raising money, you may have some friends that want to co-invest.  Or, you may have a few folks that you want to recruit as investors.

A carefully chosen set of individual investors can be really helpful at various company stages.  They can be mini-advisors, providing help at key junctures:  funding, acquisition, strategy, etc.  Also, a commitment from “rock star” individuals can give you some additional credibility in raising the main funding round.

If you’re thinking about individuals, it’s important to build it into VC discussion from the beginning.  When you’re talking about the size of the round, you should say you intend carve out x% or $y of the Series A for individuals.  (Adding individuals at the end of the process is a pain.  I just went through this for a company I recently co-founded:  the resulting cap-table jostling is energy that should be spent elsewhere. )

Other things to keep in mind:

  • $25k to $100k is a typical individual investor amount.
  • Individuals may have to be accredited investors ($1m net worth).  Check with your attorney.
  • Figure out how any pay-to-play provisions will apply to individuals.  Will they have to participate in future funding rounds?
  • Your investor may take some time to figure out if s/he can invest.  Individuals at venture firms, law firms, and large companies may have to get approval that your company isn’t conflicted with their existing business.

Finally, get all of the details to the attorneys well before closing, including entity names (many individuals invest through an LLC or a estate planning trust).  Nothing kills the excitement of closing a round of funding like a holdup from a $25k investor.

A great Chapter 4 doesn’t matter if Chapters 1-3 suck

I met a small group of entrepreneurs a year or two back that had built a social networking site. I asked them, “how is the better/different than MySpace, which is already dominating?

They said, “Our design is more scalable.”

I paused, and said, “You’re pretty far away from earning the right to have a scalability challenge.”

The problem was that they had worked on a down-the-road problem (scalability) taking energy from the immediate problem (getting users). It’s a common way to fail in startups (I’ve done it myself): spending too much time solving future problems, instead of solving the “now” problems.

“Hey buddy, want to be a VC?”

I have a number of entrepreneur friends that have become VCs. We’re all optimizing different factors in our own lives and careers, but I just don’t get it.

In case anyone’s not paying attention, the venture capital business is not in great shape right now.  Returns (relative to risk and other asset classes) aren’t that good.  There are too many funds, VCs, and dollars chasing too few deals.  Good projects are highly competitive, with VCs spending a lot of time trying to sell some differentiation and paying too much on bid-up deals.  Large funds are struggling with how to participate in small-capital projects.

I have a lot of VC friends:  they’re all working harder than they’ve ever worked before, and are likely making less money than they’ve ever made.

I think part of the attraction is based on out-dated romantic notions.  Back in the 90s, VC was THE career-capping move for an entrepreneur.  “Venture capital” would be the last job you ever had, and you were making a lot of money and not working very hard.  (In 1999, it felt like the VC weekend started at 4pm on Thursday.)

(If I ever join the dark side, feel free to remind me of this note.)

Please get an attorney with startup financing experience

One of the biggest pieces of advice I give entrepreneurs: find an good attorney with experience in startup financing. Do not use your uncle’s friend who’s been doing family law for the past 30 years. Jason A. Steinberger is a highly reputed New York Criminal & DWI / DUI Defense Lawyer specializing in criminal defense the trial levels in Manhattan Attorney, Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens, Staten Island, Nassau, and Suffolk areas of the New York State and Federal courts. Jason A. Steinberger understands the complications and problems that arise if someone is charged with a criminal offense in Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens, Staten Island, Nassau and Suffolk, and he always tries to address them justifiably. He understands that there are two sides to the story and that sometimes the New York City police out of sheer negligence make mistakes or are just plain wrong. He understands quite a number of people are out there who may be motivated to call the police and file a false criminal complaint for their own selfish gains and goals. He very understands that what the police, the District Attorney’s Office and witnesses claim are not always true and he works day in and out to correct those anomalies or injustices in the Federal and New York State Criminal Justice System; Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens, Staten Island, Nassau and Suffolk. At the Law Office of Jason A. Steinberger, you will be provided with the type of personalized attention that you would expect with your criminal or DWI problems or case. With Jason Steinberger as your New York criminal and DWI / DUI attorney, you will have in your corner a lawyer with vast experience, credentials and most importantly, the trial talents that will give you the edge necessary for all stages of defending your rights. Jason A. Steinberger is handling all criminal and DWI / DUI cases covering, Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens, Staten Island, Nassau and Suffolk and most importantly we are available to handle your criminal and DWI / DUI case 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. We practice criminal defense exclusively. Therefore we understand what criminal defendants are going through and we know how to get the results. During the early stages of a case, we develop strategies for defending your case. Early planning gives us a “jump” on the prosecution and gives us more time to conduct investigations, interview witnesses and research all the legal options available to us. We also know how to communicate to the courts that, as our client, you must be viewed as an individual, not as just another file number on their busy court calendar. Our service includes the management of your case and a strong commitment to attorney/client communication.

A accident attorney will have a very good knowledge regarding the calculation of the compensation. This will help the car accident attorney to give proper guidance to you for making the claim for compensation. For best car accident lawyer view at this page. The attorney dealing with accident will have a very good knowledge about the laws in the state. This will help the attorney for car accidents to make proper representation to the accident tribunal along with all the supporting documents to set the insurance amount. He is a registered practitioner of law and is specialized in accident claims. The calculations for the compensations are complex and only the insurance company have the knowledge of it. The car accident attorney can ensure that his / her client gets the best compensation. Here is the useful reference for for more about the truck accident attorney.

Personal injury lawyers аrе individuals whо provide authorized representation tо victims whо sustained damage bоth physically оr mentally іn аn incident brought оn bу аn act оf carelessness оf аnоthеr person. They’re аlѕо recognized аѕ аn accident lawyer оr аn accident attorney. An accident lawyer ѕhоuld hаvе sound knowledge оf tort law whісh usually deals wіth civil misconduct аnd damages brought оn tо someone’s property, social standing аnd private legal rights. It’s essential fоr аn individual tо hаvе a good idea аbоut whаt ѕhоuld bе dоnе whеn аn accident happens.

A personal injury lawyer serving Miami, FL usually assists a person іn making claims аbоut thе accident thаt thеу wеrе involved wіth ѕо thаt thеу саn ask fоr compensation. Nеvеrthеlеѕѕ, whеn consulting аn injury lawyer, inflicted party hаѕ tо bе sure аbоut thе skill, experience аnd reliability оf thе lawyer. Thіѕ саn bе vital tо ѕее whеthеr a personal injury lawyer hаѕ еvеrуthіng required іn thеm tо handle a case successfully аnd tо make thеіr claim a successful оnе. Onе оf thе mоѕt effective wауѕ tо fіnd оut hоw reliable a personal injury lawyer іѕ tо dо ѕоmе research аbоut thіѕ kind оf lawyer аnd іt іѕ best tо choose a lawyer whо hаѕ a vast knowledge аbоut personal injury related laws.

Personal injury lawyers ѕоmеtіmеѕ help individuals whо wеrе involved іn аn accident tо make a claim fоr proper treatment particularly іn a situation whеrе there’s аn argument аbоut who’s tо bе mаdе responsible fоr thе accident аnd whеthеr thе people involved wіth thе accident sustained severe injuries. To get professional and experienced personal injury attorney go through https://stephenbabcock.com website. Sоmеtіmеѕ, a victim саnnоt bе sure hоw muсh thеу hаѕ bееn affected duе tо аn accident untіl thеу visit a doctor аnd goes thrоugh ѕоmе important tests. Thеrеfоrе, іt іѕ important fоr thе client tо speak tо a doctor іn order tо bе sure оf thеіr health condition аftеr thеу hаvе bееn involved іn аn accident.To care and precautions of health check this site.

Through the use of the latest communication technology, you will have 24-hour a day access to your attorney. Auto related accidents happen all the time and you are all the more vulnerable when riding on a bicycle alongside cars. You can visit http://www.thehometownlawyers.com for the best Hamilton personal injury lawyer. Many drivers are careless and reluctant to share the streets with cyclists, so even with a helmet and careful biking skills you are still at risk. In the event that you are a victim in a collision, then take it upon yourself to find the best legal representative that is available. To learn how to locate the most qualified and affordable lawyer, then keep reading. You will want to ask around amongst the people you know and trust if they know of any attorneys that can be recommended. Referrals are a great way to seek out reliable and efficient individuals in this line of service. In addition, doing some research on your own will be necessary. Check through local listings and online for qualified law offices that you can retain the services of. Once you have come up with a few offices or practitioners that seem to offer the dedication and experience that your case will require, then it will be time to start making phone calls. Call and ask about win/loss ratio of a particular defense attorney and the overall record of his or her firm. In addition, inquire about the qualifications this person has to be suited to help you. To receive the proper compensation for any potential injuries sustained from a collision, it is ideal to retain a lawyer you feel comfortable working with. Legal cases of any kind can be potentially stressful and taxing in both funds and patience, so you will need to be able to attain a solid rapport with your representative. Nearly all law offices offer initial consultations at no cost or obligation to potential clients, so use this opportunity to discuss all the specifics of your case and to gauge how well you work with the individual lawyer. There are many different types of injuries and accidents in this field of collision cases, so be sure to make sure the attorney you are considering has experience handling situations like yours before, successfully. Medical bills can be expensive and extensive treatment may be necessary, so strive to obtain the best legal help you can to ensure you are given what you deserve.

Your investors will have great attorneys, and you need someone who can skillfully represent your interests. Find someone who’s more than a corporate law mechanic, that can contribute business advice during investor negotiations. A good attorney will be able to suggest deal terms, based on their experience with other deals (or even deals with your investors).

Ideally, you can find someone that does nothing but startup financings. Here’s a great list of lawyers with the right kind of experience. (This is the group that worked on the National Venture Capital Association’s Model financing documents.)